Maybe It's Maybelline

"Dual tip to create thin precise lines with one side, bold thick lines with the other
2-in-1 dual tip
Glossy formula for bold lines

Why You'll Love It

Experience the revolution in liquid liner: *2-in-1 tip *Glossy formula for bold lines

For Best Results

(1) use flat disk side of tip for a thick dramatic line
(2) turn 90 degrees and use for a thinner sophisticated line." - Maybelline.com

I'm extremely surprised that everything of what this product claims to be is true. The only thing that wasn't mentioned is how waterproof and long-lasting it is. 

First picture is of me putting that on at 10:30 am. Very glossy, which was in the product description. If you want more of a matte liner, I'd opt for a gel liner or a cake liner. 2 cake liners I love are made by MUD/Makeup Designory and MAC. It's kind of a hit or miss with the MAC ones. Sometimes one is less opaque then the previous one from MAC (I still love MAC). Cake liners allow you to control opaqueness just by adding more water or less - they never run and are extremely long wearing. 

At this time, it 8 hrs later and it was still on, and yes I'm very hygienic and wash my hand after touching anything (what do you expect, I'm a esthetician as well, it's a good habit). 

It doesn't seem to show much of a difference. I literally needed to scrub it off my hand. I'm sure a makeup remover off waterproof makeup will take care of that. Opt for a cheaper way, use coconut oil. 

The other eyeliner on the top right is the Prestige liquid liner. There was no comparison there. The Prestige didn't have any chance with the waterproof test. The color payoff didn't do what I expected to be.

Maybelline it! One of the best drugstore brands there is. Try there 24hr long lasting gel liner. Very comparable to high end ones. 

Give it a try!